SA’s judiciary must fight for hearts and minds to reclaim the moral high ground 03.06.2026

Public trust in South Africa's judiciary is eroding due to high-profile cases that suggest wealth and influence can shield individuals from justice. Examples include the extortion case against taxi boss Joe Sibanyoni, which was initially struck off the roll before being re-enrolled, and a fraud case against Johannesburg Development Agency CEO Themba Mathibe. Furthermore, the Nulane Investments State Capture case, initially heard by Acting Judge Nompulelelo Gusha, was controversially acquitted only for her ruling to be severely criticized and appealed by the Supreme Court of Appeal. Other controversies involve acting judge Stanley Jacobs' financial interest in a case he heard and Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge's misconduct, highlighting systemic issues. These events, coupled with deliberate campaigns to undermine the judiciary by figures like Jacob Zuma and Julius Malema, necessitate assertive action, including accountability for wrongdoing, transparency in disciplinary processes, and the assignment of seasoned judges to critical cases, to restore public confidence and the moral high ground.
















